Skip to content

Beads, Cloth and Guns: The Truth About the Gifts Europe's Explorers Gave African Kings

The popular story says African rulers were dazzled by cheap trinkets. The explorers' own journals tell a different story: of tolls set by African chiefs, beads and cloth that worked as money, and rulers who drove hard bargains. The real trick came later, and it was written on paper.

Venetian glass beads made for the trade with West Africa, on display at the Corning Museum of Glass
Venetian glass beads made for trade in West Africa. On the caravan roads, beads were money, not trinkets. Photo by Andre Carrotflower, via Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 4.0.

It was 1860, and John Hanning Speke was leading a caravan inland from the island of Zanzibar on his second journey to find the source of the Nile. The Royal Geographical Society had sent him to prove that Lake Victoria was the source of the Nile and Speke was determined to be right. It was his third African expedition, and the second in which the Nile was the prize.

At Bagamoyo, the mainland port opposite the island, the first problems had arrived before the caravan even left the beach. Speke had to hire a hundred porters, and competition among the merchants had pushed their wages up. So he had ended up paying more than nine dollars a head just to get them as far as Kaze. Then the troubles truly began. On the very first day, ten of the men the Sultan of Zanzibar had lent him for his voyage slipped away. They had decided the white men were cannibals fattening them for the interior. A porter also laid his pay on the ground and ran too.

So the caravan that eventually moved into Uzaramo in early October 1860 was already a little smaller than planned. Uzaramo, the territory of the Zaramo people, lay inland from the coast and formed part of the route Speke had to cross on his way towards Lake Victoria. Its local headmen controlled passage through their communities and expected caravans to make payments as they travelled.

Speke had been through the region before, in 1857, with Richard Burton. He thought he knew what to expect. Twelve miles from the sea, a headman called Phanze Khombe la Simba, also known as Lion's Claw, sent over a basket of rice worth about a dollar. Speke understood the arrangement.

Nobody in these parts handed over rice and expected nothing back. He told his caravan captain to give four yards of American sheeting and promptly forgot about it. Then the cloth came back.

The chief, Speke was told, could not possibly accept so little. On the earlier journey he had received far more, and if he went home with this scrap, his family would swear he had pocketed the rest. Speke did not move. His own account is blunt: he said he had paid his footing in the country the first time round and would be treated as any ordinary traveller or not at all. That put weight on his caravan captain, an Arab named Sheikh Said, a timid and well-mannered little man who carried a sword nearly as long as he was tall. Sheikh Said begged Speke to reconsider and cobbled together a bigger offering: a dubuani, a sahari and eight yards of sheeting. That came back too. The chief left in a rage, promising to visit the camp in person the next morning. Behind him, Sheikh Said sat down and began casting bullets for his rifle.

Speke called it a fair specimen of tax-gathering, a sample of what the road ahead would be like. The next day, at the next camp, a second headman, called Monkey's Tail, sent in a demand for his own “rights”. Speke, who plainly fancied himself a hard man, handed over a single dubuani and sent word that anyone who came near him again would smell his powder. “Two taxes in five miles” was unheard of, he fumed in his journal. Lion's Claw, meanwhile, had turned up again for his clothes of the day before. That evening Speke's servant Bombay told him how it had really gone. The fire-eater had refused to pay, and Sheikh Said, afraid of the consequences, had quietly paid anyway: two dubuani to Monkey's Tail, one of them out of his own store, and an extra cloth to Lion's Claw from his stores, to make him go away. Speke's pride about driving a hard bargain had cost him nothing. His caravan captain had paid the bill.

Everyone On The Coast Is A Sultan

What strikes you, reading Speke's account of those first marches, is how well the system worked, and how little it needed Speke's agreement. The headmen of Uzaramo, he noticed, lived mostly on the coast and called themselves subjects of the Sultan of Zanzibar, with the title Diwan. But the moment word arrived that a caravan was on the road, they moved inland, declared themselves sultans in their own right, and began levying taxes. The title changed with the traffic and the toll stayed.

The toll was graded. One chief at a place called Thumba Lhere took three yards of sheeting and two of the blue cloth called Kaniki “without much fuss”, Speke wrote, because he had no power. Another, a mild man called Mkungu-pare, got a modest present for his trouble and was so pleased by the courtesy that he put his estate at the traveller's disposal and even offered to hand out justice if any local was caught stealing from the caravan. What you paid depended on whom you were dealing with, and Speke understood this perfectly well. When he decided to hold the line on his cloth, he noted that he did not want to be too generous, because generosity would lower the value of merchandise and raise every chief's expectations for the travellers who followed. He was, in effect, an economist in a hurry, arguing about the price of passage with men who were doing exactly the same sum from the other side.

The payment had a name. On the caravan roads of East Africa it was hongo. Speke defined it in his own pages as the right to make whatever exactions a chief thought he had the power to enforce, with no regard for justice and no fixed tariff. European writers called it blackmail, and Speke used the word himself in the same chapter. The people collecting it would have called it a toll: the price of crossing their country, drinking at their wells and buying food in their markets.

Nowhere was the toll heavier than in Ugogo, the dry plateau of central Tanzania that every caravan had to cross on the way to the lakes. Speke's own party, in 1860, was warned that the country ahead was gripped by drought and famine. He knew the road, and he dreaded it. Thirteen years later, Lieutenant Verney Lovett Cameron crossed the same road and described the experience in a paper to the Royal Geographical Society. He had left a place called Kikoka on 28 March 1873, and was paying as much as thirty doti to a “smiling old villain” at Msuwah before the end of the first stage. By mid-year, Cameron had reached Mvume, the first district in Ugogo. There the chief and his entire court were drunk on the first day. On the second day the chief would only receive tribute through his prime minister, who was too drunk to do business. It went on like this, day after day, for three or four days.

There was no way round it, Cameron wrote, and he explained why. The Gogo did not usually fight. If a caravan refused the demand, they simply carried off everything they could of their provisions, destroyed their houses, filled in their water holes and retired to the bush, leaving the strangers to die of thirst and hunger. That is a more effective enforcement system than a regiment, because it costs nothing and nobody can argue with it. Cameron noted that several Arab caravans had tried to avoid paying and had learned the lesson the hard way, more than once.

Explorers were not singled out. When Speke reached Usui, he found an Arab merchant named Asudi who had been sitting there for a fortnight because the king had not received him, and until he did, Asudi could not settle his hongo and could not move. The ivory traders of Zanzibar, who ran the ivory trade, paid at the same toll gates as everyone else. A European traveller was one more customer on a road that somebody else owned. At Khoko, Cameron's caravan and the others travelling with it, about five hundred men in all, camped under a single enormous tree. In the last district, the chief's headman insisted that the whole party wait until all the local people had seen the white men, and made a show of them.

In 1871, eleven years after Speke's journey, another British explorer encountered the same system at Bagamoyo. Henry Morton Stanley, a journalist working for the New York Herald, had arrived in East Africa on an expedition to find the missing explorer David Livingstone. Before he could begin the journey inland, he had to assemble his own caravan and negotiate the demands of local chiefs. Tribute, he found, had to be packed separately from everything else, in choice cloth. Chiefs would not touch the thin stuff the porters carried. They wanted dear coloured clothes, or even crimson broadcloth. The tribute for his first small caravan cost $25, and by his own reckoning the whole bill would come to about $330 in gold. Stanley's Arab and Indian advisers also gave him a practical tip: send small caravans, not large ones. Large caravans invited attacks or got held up by greedy chiefs on the slightest pretext, while small ones passed without notice.

Money In A Bale

Beyond Zanzibar, coin was nearly useless. Stanley arrived there on 6 January 1871 with orders from the New York Herald to find David Livingstone, and discovered at once that he had no idea how much cloth would feed a hundred men. Nobody in the European community did either. He had read Burton and Speke from cover to cover, and neither had thought to include a chapter on how to equip an expedition. He ended up at the house of an old Arab merchant, Sheikh Hashid, who told him that ten doti a day, forty yards, would feed a hundred men on the road.

From that figure Stanley built his shopping list. For a year he needed 2,000 doti of American sheeting, 1,000 of the blue cloth called kaniki, and 650 of coloured cloth. For two years, double it: 16,000 yards, 8,000 yards and 5,200 yards. He added twenty-two sacks of beads in eleven varieties and ten frasilah of brass wire, about 350 pounds. Beads, he was told, did the work of copper coins in the interior, cloth the work of silver, and wire the work of gold.

These weren't trinkets. They were cash, and like any currency their value depended on what people would accept, which was fiercely local. Black beads, Stanley learned, were money in Ugogo and worthless everywhere else. The red beads called sami-sami would buy anything in Unyamwezi, where nothing else would. The egg beads prized in Ujiji would be refused in every other country. Burton and Speke, he noted, had been forced to throw away several hundred fundo of beads after guessing wrong. According to him, it was like setting out across Europe on foot with a sack of napoleons that nobody in Prussia would take.

Carrying it all was a negotiation of its own. Porters would not lift much more than seventy pounds. His first bales, packed by a Zanzibar merchant who simply guessed at the weights, came in at 105 pounds, thirty-five over the limit. Stanley watched a couple of porters try to lift them, grunt and give up, and then hung one on a spring balance to see the problem for himself. He had to unpack everything and rebuild it. By his own count he was moving at least six tons of goods, which at seventy pounds a man needed nearly 160 carriers. Carrying a single load of seventy pounds as far as Unyanyembe cost fifteen dollars a head.

Getting the carriers at all was another matter. Arab and Swahili merchants were paying twenty doti to each porter, and many of them had been waiting up to six months for a full complement. Stanley offered twenty-five and wasted six weeks at Bagamoyo working through a young Indian agent who kept padding the accounts. The final bill started at $1,400 in cash and was eventually knocked down to $738. Stanley's verdict on the young man's honesty is not printable in a family newspaper.

Mistakes could end an expedition. When Cameron's porters were paid in cloth they judged to be of poor quality, they decided they had been cheated, and many deserted. Fee's summary of the period is blunt: the explorers were “hostage to cloth,” at the mercy of the chiefs whose land they crossed and of the porters who carried their loads.

He eventually left on 21 March, with a hundred and ninety-two souls in five caravans. On his way out of Bagamoyo he passed the caravan the British Consul had sent to relieve Livingstone, which had been sitting there for a hundred days for the want of thirty-five porters. The road kept getting more dreary. A reviewer of Cameron's book in 1877 noted that Burton, in the late 1850s, had been able to buy sixty-four rations for a doti in Ugogo, and that Cameron could never get more than twenty. Every caravan that passed pushed the price up for the next.

Gifts That Ran Both Ways

Between rulers and travellers of rank, gifts were also diplomacy, and they didn't only flow one way.

On 3 November 1855 David Livingstone left Linyanti, the Makololo capital, to follow the Zambezi towards the east coast. The Makololo king, Sekeletu, went with him, along with about two hundred followers, all fed at his expense. At Sesheke the king supplied Livingstone with twelve oxen, three of them trained to be ridden, along with hoes and beads to buy a canoe once they reached the river beyond the falls. On that journey the African king was the patron and the Scottish missionary was the guest.

In Buganda the traffic was in guns. Kabaka Mutesa I had sent an invitation to Speke through his friend Rumanika, king of Karagwe. Speke had seen what that meant before he reached Mutesa's palace, because at Rumanika's request he gave Mutesa's pages some ammunition to carry ahead to their master, who had sent for “strengthening powder” and powder for his gun. Speke reached the palace on 19 February 1862 and spent four months negotiating there, among them a good deal of shooting. He sent the king a double-barrelled gun and ammunition. Before long Mutesa was returning Speke's rifle, borrowing another gun and turning up at the palace gate in the mornings ready for a shooting trip, with his chiefs and pages and a train of women behind.

When Stanley arrived at the court thirteen years later, Mutesa used him too. He asked Stanley to write down an invitation for Christian teachers. Stanley's letter ran in London's Daily Telegraph on 15 November 1875, after Colonel Ernest Linant de Bellefonds, who had met Stanley at the court and agreed to carry the letter, was killed in Sudan before he could deliver it. It found its way to London anyway. The first missionaries reached Buganda in 1877. A little later one of them, Alexander Mackay, recorded the king's questions about a new party of Europeans. They kept coming back to guns. Were they breech-loaders? Would they bring powder? Would they bring beads? It wasn't the cross-examination of a man easily dazzled.

When The Gifts Became A Purchase Price

The story changed in the 1880s, as Europe's governments began the Scramble for Africa. Gifts that had once bought passage or friendship were now offered in exchange for signatures. From 1879 to 1884, Stanley worked on the Congo River for Leopold II of Belgium, who disguised his ambitions behind a string of charitable-sounding associations. By 1884 Stanley had gathered more than 300 treaties from local chiefs, and he later claimed over 450. Leopold was impatient for more. In an angry letter to a colleague in October 1882, he complained that Stanley's treaties did not satisfy him. They ought to say, in so many words, that the chiefs delegated their sovereign rights to the Association, and they should be short. Two articles, ideally, that in his words, “must grant us everything.”

One of the treaties shows how that worked in practice. On 1 April 1884 the chiefs of Ngombi and Mafela, near South Manyanga, agreed to give up the sovereignty and all governing rights over their territories to the International Association. In return they were to receive one piece of cloth per month each, plus a present of cloth on the spot. They also promised to help with labour “or otherwise” on any works the Association chose to carry out. Hochschild notes that Stanley's presents for chiefs were not to omit a couple of bottles of gin.

The idea of a treaty of friendship between two clans or villages was familiar. The idea of signing a country over to someone on the far side of the ocean was not. Most of the chiefs could not read the documents, which were drawn up in a European language, and had no means of knowing what their marks meant in European law. The United States became the first country to recognise Leopold's claim, in April 1884. At the Berlin Conference that winter the great powers added their approval, and the treaties became the foundation of the Congo Free State.

Stanley's treaties became the legal foundation of Leopold's Congo Free State.

Further south, four years later, three agents of Cecil Rhodes put a different offer to Lobengula, king of the Ndebele. He had spent months being besieged by concession-hunters, and the British officials around him, among them John Moffat, were telling him that dealing with one large company, backed by Queen Victoria, would be easier than dealing with a crowd. Moffat himself had written to a friend a few weeks earlier that the king was far from a free agent, because the fighting men behind him were jealous and suspicious.

On 30 October 1888, Lobengula put his mark on the Rudd Concession. It gave Charles Rudd, Rochfort Maguire and Francis Thompson complete and exclusive charge over all the metals and minerals in his kingdom, and the right to keep other concession-seekers out. In return he was to get £100 on the first day of every lunar month, a thousand Martini-Henry breech-loading rifles, a hundred thousand cartridges, and a steamboat with guns on the Zambezi, or £500 if he preferred the money. It's not just a tray of beads. Lobengula was being offered the best rifles then available, and a steady income. The missionary Charles Helm, who interpreted for him, later said that Rudd had made spoken promises that never reached the paper: “Not more than ten white men would work in the country. They would not dig near his towns. They and their people would obey his laws.” None of that was in the document. By January 1889, the Cape newspapers were reporting that the king had sold his country. In June his regiments demanded to know whether he had sold it for guns. The British government granted Rhodes's company a royal charter on 29 October 1889, and in 1890 the Pioneer Column, 196 men promised farms and mining claims, marched into Mashonaland.

Lobengula had looked at the paper and seen a licence to dig. The company saw the foundation of a colony. In 1918 the Privy Council in London ruled that, under customary law, Lobengula had never had the authority to give away Ndebele land in the first place, and the land belonged to the Crown. By then he had been dead for twenty-four years.

What The Gifts Really Were

The legend of the gullible chief suits a story in which Europeans were clever and Africans were easily fooled. The record shows the opposite for most of the century. African rulers charged tolls, set prices, rejected poor goods and made explorers wait. Beads and cloth were not toys but money, and the people who used them knew exactly what they were worth.

Where Africans were deceived, it was not by glass but by law: by treaties written in languages they could not read, and enforced by armies that arrived after the ink was dry.

So here is the question: ‘If African rulers drove hard bargains for a hundred years, why is the image of the chief swapping his land for a string of beads still the one most people believe? And who benefits from keeping it alive?’

Oluwatetisimi Ariyo

Oluwatetisimi Ariyo

Oluwatetisimi Ariyo is a seasoned writer with extensive experience crafting compelling and conversion-focused content for top global brands.

All articles

More in Colonial Africa

See all

More from Oluwatetisimi Ariyo

See all