In 1817, a young British envoy named Thomas Bowdich walked into Kumasi, the capital of the Asante kingdom, and was impressed. He described a city about four miles around, with twenty-seven streets, each under the authority of a captain. The four main avenues were half a mile long and fifty to a hundred yards wide. Most houses had toilets, often upstairs, flushed daily with boiling water, and the city's rubbish was burned every morning. Twenty-two years later, a Methodist missionary called its streets cleaner than those of any African town he had seen.
In 1874, a British officer named William Butler entered the same city with an invading army. He called it a filthier and far more blood-stained collection of mud and wattle hovels than any forest village.
The same city. Two descriptions that cannot both be the whole truth. After reading a great many of these accounts, we have come to a conclusion that explains most of the contradictions. Pre-colonial Africa was enormously diverse and the outsiders who wrote about it were writing for audiences with expectations. As Africa's societies were deeply unequal, a visitor could describe a palace or a hovel in the same kingdom and be accurate either way.
A Part of the Whole
Without having visited Africa oneself, it is easy to mistake Africa as simply being a big village; a perception that has found its way into the minds of many people across the world. Just as Africa is an intricately diverse place comprising numerous countries, cities, towns, villages, citadels, institutions, markets etc today, so it was in pre-colonial Africa. On the same continent and at the same time, there were hunter-gatherer bands in the Kalahari who made it a rule to mock any hunter who boasted, and cities like Kano whose cloth was worn from Tripoli to the Atlantic. There were Igbo communities with no kings at all, governed by councils and assemblies, and imperial courts like Mali's, where the ruler sat beneath a silk umbrella crowned with a golden bird.
So, when a single author presents a part of Africa and seeks to represent it as the whole, it's worth asking what has been left out. A traveller who saw one of these places and wrote "Africa is..." was always describing a part and calling it the whole. That was the first distortion. A traveller who spent his time in an affluent royal court might return with stories of wealth, elaborate ceremonies and political sophistication. Another, whose journey took him through a poor settlement or a community recovering from war, might write of poverty, disorder and hardship. Neither account necessarily cancels out the other. The problem begins when either is treated as a portrait of the entire continent.
This is one of the difficulties of reading European accounts of pre-colonial Africa. Their authors often encountered different societies, different classes of people and different conditions, even within the same kingdom. Their observations were also shaped by where they travelled, whom they met, what they were permitted to see and the assumptions they carried with them. To understand the Africa they described, we must look beyond the descriptions themselves and consider the circumstances in which they were written.
The Explorers Wrote For the Expectations of an Audience
The best-known explorers were not neutral observers. They were funded by newspapers, geographical societies, churches and governments, and they sold books and lecture tickets to a public that wanted adventure, danger and moral purpose.
Henry Morton Stanley went looking for David Livingstone in 1871 on the orders of James Gordon Bennett Jr., owner of the New York Herald, a newspaper that needed a story. His next expedition was paid for by the Herald and London's Daily Telegraph. He called the resulting book Through the Dark Continent, a phrase that helped fix an image of Africa in the European mind for a century. Stanley spent his later years defending himself against charges of brutality, and wrote that "the savage only respects force, power, boldness, and decision." A continent of darkness and savagery was not only what he saw. It was what his readers paid for, and what justified the way he travelled.
Editors shaped the record too. Livingstone's last journals reached the public through Horace Waller, whose edition one modern biographer has called "emollient," smoothing the explorer's image into that of a saint. And some of the most influential European writings about Africa came from people who never went. The philosopher Georg Hegel, lecturing in the 1820s that Africa had no historical interest of its own, drew heavily on Bowdich's book about Asante, and, as one recent study shows, reversed it where it did not suit him. Bowdich wrote that the king was heir to the gold of every subject; Hegel made it all their property. Bowdich described royal bones bathed in rum and water; Hegel had them washed in human blood.
Not every audience wanted darkness, though. Mungo Park's Travels of 1799, which praised the kindness of the African women and enslaved people who kept him alive, became a best-seller and was used by campaigners against the slave trade. But in every case, what was printed was chosen with readers in mind. And the timing mattered. Butler wrote his description of Kumasi against the backdrop of the British invasion of Asante in 1874. By the time British forces reached the capital in February, the Asante had abandoned the city. The British occupied it, entered the royal palace and seized its treasures. Within days, the palace was blown up, and fires consumed substantial parts of the city. Butler's description therefore needs to be read in the context of a military campaign and the destruction surrounding the fall of the Asante capital. A visitor arriving in Kumasi in these circumstances was encountering a city under the immediate effects of war, not necessarily the city that Bowdich had described decades earlier. The distinction is important. Butler may have recorded what he saw, but his description cannot, by itself, establish what Kumasi had been like before the invasion.
Vast Inequalities
Many pre-colonial African societies were profoundly unequal. The gap between the court and the countryside, between the free and the enslaved, could be enormous.
For instance, Ibn Battuta, who visited Mali in 1352, described both worlds in the same pages. He watched the ruler emerge to the sound of gold and silver instruments, with three hundred armed slaves around him. He also watched subjects who came before the king strip off their fine clothes, put on worn garments and humble themselves before him, and young servant girls who went about unclothed. He praised Mali's security and its hatred of injustice. Both were true.
The archaeology says the same. At Mapungubwe, in today's South Africa, rulers were buried with gold on a hilltop while their people lived below. At Great Zimbabwe, the elite lived behind stone walls and ate from Chinese porcelain, while most of the city lived in houses of mud and timber. In the Sokoto Caliphate, historians estimate that between a quarter and a half of the population was enslaved. A French census of West Africa in 1904 recorded between 30 and 50 percent of people as unfree.
So when a European wrote of poverty, hard labour or slavery, he was often describing something real. And when Bowdich wrote of Kumasi's broad streets, he was describing something equally real: the capital of a rich and powerful elite.
The pattern did not end with colonial rule. Stand in Lagos today and you could write either Bowdich's report or Butler's, just as can be found in every contemporary society across the world. On Banana Island, Nigeria's most expensive neighbourhood and home to Aliko Dangote, Africa's richest man, the mansions rival any in the world. Across the lagoon in Makoko, tens of thousands of people live in houses on stilts over the water, and in 2012 the state demolished part of the community on 72 hours' notice. In 2025, Oxfam calculated that Africa's four richest people held $57.4 billion, more than the roughly 750 million people who make up the poorer half of the continent. The World Bank has ranked South Africa's income inequality the highest it measures anywhere.
A foreign reporter today can describe a gleaming Africa or a desperate one and be accurate either way. The distance between the palace and the hut has not closed. In many places it has simply changed its address.
Why The Outsider's Picture Felt Familiar
This is why the European picture of Africa took hold even among many Africans. Most of us, even those whose ancestors lived inside great kingdoms, descend from farmers, herders, servants and the enslaved, not from the court. When a colonial-era book described a hard, poor and unfree life, it matched what many families remembered of their own past, even if, a day's walk away, a small elite in the same society had lived in a very different world.
The same trap catches us today in reverse. The popular modern picture of pre-colonial Africa as a land of kings, gold and universities selects a different stratum, the court and the scholars, and calls it the whole. It is no more complete than Stanley's darkness.
How To Read The Sources
The old accounts are some of the richest records we have. But they have to be read with four questions in mind. Who paid for the journey? Who was the book written to please? Where did the writer stand: in the palace, the market or the slave pen? And what was happening at the time, whether a trade mission, a missionary campaign or a war?
Ask those questions and the contradictions start to make sense. Bowdich and Butler were both looking at Kumasi. One was a guest of the king in peacetime. The other was an invader in a burning city. Ancient writers, too, filled the gaps in their knowledge of Africa with what their readers expected, and the Portuguese who first mapped the African coast recorded their own arrival rather than what was already there.
Africa before colonial rule was neither the dark continent of the Victorian imagination nor a golden age of kings. It was a vast range of societies, some simple and some highly organised, almost all of them with a wide distance between the people at the top and the people at the bottom. Honest history holds both.
So here is the question, ‘When you picture African ancestors before colonial rule, do you see them at court, or in the fields? And which picture have you been taught to prefer?’