Skip to content

Sung Out of the Village: The Role of Shame in Pre-Colonial Africa

Long before police and prisons, many African societies kept order with a different weapon: public shame. Before a complaint reached a court, it could reach the whole village.

A carved and painted Yoruba Gelede helmet mask
A Yoruba Gelede headdress. Behind the mask, singers named the corrupt and the cruel in broad daylight. Photo: Glenbow Museum, via Wikimedia Commons, CC0.

Imagine three distinct scenarios. A man beats his wife. Another allows his cows to destroy a neighbour's crops. A third repeatedly breaks the rules governing the market. In some precolonial Igbo communities of southeastern Nigeria, these offenses could bring an entire gathering of women to each offender's compound.

They came together, sometimes with their faces painted and wearing ferns, sometimes at night, singing songs that announced their grievances to the neighbourhood. They danced, beat the walls of the offender's house with wooden pestles used for pounding yams and made enough noise to ensure that everyone knew why they had come. They might even plaster his house with mud, damage it or physically rough him up. The women could remain at his compound throughout the day and into the night at times. At least, until he repented and promised to change his behaviour. It was allowed. It was legal. It was a form of shaming him into aligning himself with expected social rules and norms.

This practice became known in English as 'sitting on a man.' Despite its name, women could also use it against another woman. It was one of the ways through which Igbo women collectively defended their interests and demanded that offenders answer for their behaviour. The women did not act alone or simply because they were angry. Their collective action was rooted in women's own political organisation. They held meetings where they discussed matters affecting them and agreed on how to respond when their interests were threatened. The political scientist Judith Van Allen, in her 1972 study, 'Sitting on a Man: Colonialism and the Lost Political Institutions of Igbo Women,' documented how this practice formed part of a wider system of women's political authority.

Order Beyond the Courtroom

Most African societies before colonial rule had no police force and no prisons. Many had no chiefs with the power to compel. Disputes went to elders and councils, and serious matters to oracles or specialised societies. But the everyday work of keeping people in line was done by something cheaper and more pervasive: the knowledge that the whole community was watching, and that a disgrace would follow not only you but your family.

That collective dimension mattered. In a study of Akan proverbs from Ghana, researchers noted that people were expected to avoid behaviour that would bring shame "on themselves, and by extension their kin." A thief shamed his lineage. A cowardly son shamed his mother. Because reputation was shared, families had every reason to discipline their own members before the village had to.

The Shame Songs

Public criticism did not always happen at someone's doorstep. In some communities, it became a performance accompanied by drums, dance and carefully aimed insults.

Among the Anlo Ewe of southeastern Ghana, one such performance was known as haló, a dramatic contest of insult songs with drumming, dance, mime and costume. The performance brought together groups from different villages or wards, who challenged one another through songs, spoken insults, dance, mime and dramatic enactments. Performers could use personal insults and accusations, including claims that one group had taken another's wife. Sometimes, the exchanges could be sharp, entertaining and deeply provocative. Elders were also known to supply the composers with embarrassing private histories, while the songs exaggerated their targets' physical features, family secrets, thefts and deceptions.

The form documented by the ethnomusicologist Daniel Avorgbedor belongs mostly to the twentieth century: haló was at its height from about 1912 until it was officially banned under Ghana's Criminal Code in 1960. He also notes that haló was violent at its core. The insults were so wounding that performances often broke into fighting. While this documentation is from postcolonial African society, its roots stem from precolonial Africa.

Among the Yoruba of southwestern Nigeria, another masked song performance was Gelede. Its songs criticised corruption, witchcraft and other behaviour that undermined social harmony. The verses were delivered in broad daylight and aimed at prominent members of society, including chiefs.

Audiences generally knew whom the verses were directed at, while the singer spoke from behind a sacred mask.

Masked secret societies across West and Central Africa did similar work, appearing in public to expose and fine wrongdoers whose names everyone already knew.

Shame That Could Reach the Powerful

Public shame was not always directed downwards, at people with little influence. In some settings, it could also restrain those who might otherwise use their success or status to place themselves above others.

Among the Ju/'hoansi hunter-gatherers of the Kalahari, the target was anyone whose success threatened to make him arrogant. When a hunter brought home a large kill, his companions mocked it as thin and worthless. In his 1969 account, Eating Christmas in the Kalahari, anthropologist Richard B. Lee, asked why a man would be mocked after killing an animal and sharing its meat. An elder explained that a young man who killed much meat might begin to think of himself as a "big man" and regard others as his inferiors. The community therefore spoke of his meat as worthless to cool his pride and make him gentle. Shame here kept a society equal. The point was not that the hunter had committed an offence by being successful. He was expected to share what he had obtained, and the teasing discouraged him from turning that success into superiority over others. It was a way of keeping social relationships on more equal terms.

Atonement

In precolonial Africa, accountability did not always have to end in permanent disgrace. Some communities had ways of addressing an accusation and preventing a dispute from becoming a cycle of retaliation.

Among the Azande of Central Africa, E. E. Evans-Pritchard recorded a procedure used when a poison oracle identified someone as the witch responsible for another person's illness. The relatives of the sick person did not necessarily confront the accused directly. Instead, a messenger delivered a chicken's wing to him as an indication of the oracle's verdict.

The accused man would take water into his mouth and spray it over the wing. In doing so, he would say that, if he had harmed the sick person through witchcraft, he wished for the person's recovery and asked that the witchcraft within him become cool. The messenger would then report the response to the sick person's relatives.

Evans-Pritchard recorded the Azande saying, 'The blower of water does not die.' The saying referred to the belief that this procedure could protect both the sick person and the accused from the violence that might follow an unresolved accusation. The act was expected to be sincere; blowing water without genuinely wishing the sick person well was not considered enough. The same logic runs through the reconciliation traditions many African societies developed, in which the wrongdoer was named and heard, and then brought back in. Sitting on a man ended when the man made amends. The goal was usually to repair the offender, not to destroy him.

On the other hand, if the sick person died, the situation changed sharply and the possibility of a loved one seeking vengeance loomed.

The Cruel Side of Shame

Just like most things, there was another side to using shame as a method of social control. For instance, the same community that could unite to confront a violent husband could also unite against someone who had done little or nothing to deserve its anger.

As a result, public ridicule could become a weapon against people with less power and influence; for example, women whose circumstances did not meet social expectations, people with disabilities, the poor, or anyone accused of conduct the community feared or misunderstood.

The Anlo-Ewe haló performances show how quickly this could happen. Avorgbedor describes insults that grew from one performance to the next, sometimes leading to physical fights and hostility that continued long after the singing had stopped. Even in the Igbo example, the action could go beyond embarrassment. Women might damage a man's house or rough him up. The fact that the practice was recognised as a legitimate means of enforcing women's decisions did not make every action harmless.

Public shame could hold people accountable, but it could also humiliate, intimidate and punish. Its fairness depended on who made the accusation, whose voices were heard and whether the person being confronted had a meaningful opportunity to respond.

Colonial Integration and the Resulting Women-Led War

In November 1929, women in southeastern Nigeria turned to a familiar form of collective protest against the colonial administration and the warrant chiefs who represented it.

The events that became known to the British as the Aba Riots are remembered by Igbo women as the Women's War, or Ogu Umunwanyi. The resistance involved predominantly Igbo and Ibibio women, alongside women from other communities in the region. It began at Oloko in Owerri Province and spread across the Eastern Provinces.

The immediate trigger at Oloko was a census exercise. A colonial official had ordered a recount of households and their property, including property belonging to women. Although the administration gave assurances that the exercise would not introduce a new tax on women, many women did not believe those assurances. Men were already paying tax, and the women feared that the counting of their property was preparation for extending taxation to them. Their anger was also rooted in resentment of the warrant chiefs, some of whom had abused the authority given to them by the colonial government.

The confrontation that set events in motion occurred on 23 November 1929. An agent of the Oloko warrant chief, Okugo, approached a woman named Nwanyeruwa and asked her to count her goats and sheep. She challenged him, asking whether his mother had been counted. The exchange became physical, and Nwanyeruwa reported what had happened to the other women. They mobilised through their market and kinship networks, and the protest spread.

The women demanded assurances that they would not be taxed and called for the removal of warrant chiefs they considered abusive. They gathered at administrative centres, sang and danced, confronted chiefs and, in some places, destroyed Native Court buildings. Their actions drew on the organisation and methods of women's collective protest, including the practice of sitting on an offender. Van Allen describes women appearing with their faces smeared with charcoal or ashes, their heads bound with young ferns and their sticks decorated with young palms which carried meanings associated with the women's protest and its traditional forms.

Thousands of women took part. The colonial government responded with police and troops. In clashes at different locations, colonial soldiers shot and killed more than fifty women. Van Allen records that the deaths occurred during two major confrontations and that the women killed were women participants.

The Women's War forced the colonial government to reconsider its system of indirect rule in southeastern Nigeria. The warrant chief system was eventually abandoned and replaced by different forms of village and clan councils during the reforms of the 1930s. But the changes did not restore women's political influence. Van Allen notes that women were generally excluded from the reformed Native Administration, even though their political organisation had helped make the rebellion possible.

What Happened to the Power of the Village?

The colonial encounter changed the conditions under which many communities exercised authority. In the Igbo areas described by Van Allen, colonial officials created a Native Administration that concentrated authority in warrant chiefs and Native Courts. The administration also restricted the use of collective force against wrongdoers. Practices such as sitting on a man could consequently be treated as unlawful, while women were expected to take their complaints to courts in which they had little influence.

This was not simply the replacement of a lawless society with a system of courts. Igbo communities already had assemblies, women's meetings, market regulations and recognised ways of settling disputes. Colonial rule reorganised political authority and weakened some of the institutions through which women had exercised power. The consequences were particularly serious where new colonial institutions did not give women an equivalent voice.

Public shame did not disappear. People continued to care about their reputations, and communities continued to criticise behaviour they considered unacceptable. But the institutions that once gave collective action its authority did not remain untouched. In the Igbo case, the loss of women's political influence was part of a much wider change in how local authority was organised.

Today, social media offers a very different kind of public exposure. A private dispute can become a public spectacle within hours. Personal histories are pulled into arguments, accusations are repeated, and strangers join in passing judgement. There are moments when public attention helps expose wrongdoing that might otherwise have been ignored. There are also moments when the crowd becomes the punishment, with little interest in whether the accusation is true or whether the person being condemned has any way to answer.

The comparison is not exact. A village assembly, a women's political organisation and an online crowd are different things. But the question they raise is familiar: when a community decides that someone has done wrong, what stops its judgement from becoming another form of injustice?

Oluwatetisimi Ariyo

Oluwatetisimi Ariyo

Oluwatetisimi Ariyo is a seasoned writer with extensive experience crafting compelling and conversion-focused content for top global brands.

All articles

More in Pre-Colonial Africa

See all

More from Oluwatetisimi Ariyo

See all